Best Supernatural games - Crit

Discover Tags Deals Hidden gems Studios

Filters

Sort by

Relevance

Hot right now

Trending

Best discount

Controversial

Top rated

Most played

Verdict

Buy681

Wait966

Skip329

Popular tags

Adventure(3,884)Atmospheric(3,332)3D(2,663)Dark(2,613)Action(2,410)2D(1,574)Casual(1,484)Action-Adventure(1,438)Choices Matter(1,094)Dark Fantasy(746)Combat(662)Cinematic(598)Anime(577)Controller(549)Colorful(532)Choose Your Own Adventure(531)

Price

Any price

Free

Under $10

Under $20

Under $60

Operating system

Windows5,923

macOS874

Linux730

Steam Deck239

On sale only

5,926 results

Supernatural

Paper Lily - Chapter 1Pixel Graphics · Psychological Horror
99% · Overwhelmingly Positive18 playingFree
Project Kat - Paper Lily ProloguePsychological Horror · Pixel Graphics
99% · Overwhelmingly PositiveNobody playingFree
The Mermaid MaskDetective · Adventure · 20% off
99% · Overwhelmingly PositiveNot tracked$15.99
A Date with DeathDating Sim · Visual Novel
98% · Overwhelmingly Positive155 playingFree
Crow CountrySurvival Horror · 1990's
98% · Overwhelmingly Positive28 playing$19.99
The Children of ClayHorror · Atmospheric
98% · Overwhelmingly Positive2 playingFree
FireworkHorror · Indie
97% · Overwhelmingly Positive25 playing$9.99
Sally Face - Episode OneStory Rich · Psychological Horror
97% · Overwhelmingly Positive140 playing$2.99
Sorry We're ClosedLGBTQ+ · Survival Horror
98% · Overwhelmingly Positive4 playing$24.99
PsychopompPsychological Horror · Horror
97% · Overwhelmingly Positive1 playingFree
A Space for the UnboundStory Rich · Pixel Graphics · 3% off
97% · Overwhelmingly Positive6 playing$19.10
Ghost Trick: Phantom DetectivePuzzle · Adventure
97% · Overwhelmingly Positive64 playing$29.99

1
2
494

Crit

Your game-buying sidekick. It reads real player reviews and tracks live prices, then tells you what's worth it and what to skip.

Product

Discover Today's deals Hidden gems Featured this week

Company

About How it works Studios Contact

Legal

Privacy Terms Affiliate disclosure

Crit is an independent project and is not affiliated with Valve or Steam. Steam and the Steam logo are trademarks of Valve Corporation. All other trademarks are property of their respective owners. All times are UTC.

2026 Crit. Made for people who min-max their backlog.