Buy it if you like
- Story: 71 reviews raised it, mostly praise
- Difficulty: 25 reviews raised it, mostly praise
- Graphics: 22 reviews raised it, mostly praise
Think twice if you dislike
- Bugs: 8 reviews raised it, mostly criticism
Based on 343 player reviews · updated
What players think
The recurring themes across 162 analysed reviews: what players praise, what divides them, and what to know.
Why players love itThings to know
72% of themes are praise14% are divided14% are complaints
Story
Players who bring up Story mostly praise it.
71 of 162 sampled reviews raised it
Coming up with a strong and interesting story, this is a great game for its genre.
Difficulty
Players who bring up Difficulty mostly praise it.
25 of 162 sampled reviews raised it
The puzzles are challenging, and there are several difficulty options you can choose from, affecting the amount of help the game gives in the form of visual cues or hints.
Graphics
Players who bring up Graphics mostly praise it.
22 of 162 sampled reviews raised it
The graphics are correct, though I found the character I was incarning not so well-proportionned.
Gameplay
Players who bring up Gameplay mostly praise it.
17 of 162 sampled reviews raised it
New York Mysteries: Secrets of the Mafia is one great HOG, with hours of gameplay, imaginative puzzles that I haven't seen before which comes with comparatively logical item combination.
Audio
Players who bring up Audio mostly praise it.
14 of 162 sampled reviews raised it
In addition, the graphics and voice acting is decent for a HOG.
Theme by theme
Scored on what reviews say about each topic, not the thumbs.
Players love
Story71 reviews
Difficulty25 reviews
Graphics22 reviews
Gameplay17 reviews
Audio14 reviews
Divided opinion
Interface100% still recommend
Players complain
Bugs38% still recommend
What you get
Can you play it alone, does a controller work, does it run on your machine.
Play modes
- Single-player
Controller
Steam lists no controller support.
Store features
- Family Sharing
- Steam Achievements
- Steam Cloud
Platforms
- Windows
- macOS
Valve device support
Steam DeckPlayable
SteamOSPlayable
Steam MachinePlayable
Should I buy it now?
Based on Steam price history.
Prices have been lower
$9.99
The lowest we've tracked is $4.99.
5 points recordedtoday · $9.99
If you liked this one
Reviewed games that overlap most with this one.
No recommendations for this game yet.
This game doesn’t overlap enough with games Crit has reviewed.