Cookie Cutter: Overkill Edition

Buy75%

Mostly Positive · 1k player reviews · Medium confidence

Worth it for the right player.

Subcult Joint LTD · Metroidvania · Dec 14, 2023

Player review score
75%
Mostly Positive
Price
$19.99
Playing right now
All-time peak
Not charted

Steam only charts its most-played games, and this one isn’t among them.

Achievements
36
total to unlock
Steam does not publish achievement rarity.
Languages
12
Full audio1 of 12
Subtitles12 of 12

Should I buy Cookie Cutter: Overkill Edition?

Buy it if you like
  • Gameplay: 112 reviews raised it, mostly praise
  • Graphics: 74 reviews raised it, mostly praise
  • Audio: 40 reviews raised it, mostly praise
Think twice if you dislike
  • Combat: 155 reviews raised it, mostly criticism
  • Story: 97 reviews raised it, mostly criticism
  • Bugs: 49 reviews raised it, mostly criticism

Based on 1k player reviews · updated

What players think

The recurring themes across 300 analysed reviews: what players praise, what divides them, and what to know.

Why players love itThings to know
25% of themes are praise300 helpful reviews75% are complaints
Gameplay
Players who bring up Gameplay mostly praise it.
112 of 300 sampled reviews raised it
The game makes smart use of the various powers and weapons you get, with most of them being usable for both combat and progression, rather than being exclusively for one or the other.
Graphics
Players who bring up Graphics mostly praise it.
74 of 300 sampled reviews raised it
Anyway, the art style and hand-drawn animation are smooth and captivating, and really were the whole reason I was drawn to it in the first place.
Audio
Players who bring up Audio mostly praise it.
40 of 300 sampled reviews raised it
The voice acting of the remake/overkill edition was also a nice touch, and it helped to bring most of the characters to life, although some actors and characters still felt a bit blended.

Theme by theme

Scored on what reviews say about each topic, not the thumbs.

Players love
Gameplay112 reviews
Graphics74 reviews
Audio40 reviews
Divided opinion

No themes split opinion in this sample.

Players complain
Combat
63% still recommend
Story
68% still recommend
Bugs
59% still recommend
Difficulty
75% still recommend
Characters
48% still recommend
Steam Deck
61% still recommend
Interface
33% still recommend
Performance
56% still recommend
Optimization
67% still recommend

What you get

Can you play it alone, does a controller work, does it run on your machine.

Play modes

  • Single-player

Controller

  • DualSense Controller Support
  • DualShock Controller Support
  • Full controller support
  • Gamepad Recommended

Store features

  • Family Sharing
  • Steam Achievements
  • Steam Cloud

Platforms

  • Windows

Valve device support

Steam DeckVerified
SteamOSPlayable
Steam MachineVerified

Should I buy it now?

Based on Steam price history.

Full price
$19.99

We haven't seen it on sale yet.

2 points recordedtoday · $19.99

If you liked this one

Reviewed games that overlap most with this one.

No recommendations for this game yet.

This game doesn’t overlap enough with games Crit has reviewed.