It depends on what you're after.
At $19.99. It has been as low as $1.99.
- Graphics: 16 reviews raised it, mostly praise
- Gameplay: 14 reviews raised it, mostly praise
- Story and characters: 7 reviews raised it, mostly praise
- Bugs: 8 reviews raised it, mostly criticism
Based on 263 player reviews · updated 4 days ago
What players think
The recurring themes across 113 analysed reviews: what players praise, what divides them, and what to know.
The bright, toy-like graphics make buildings easy to identify, resource flow is cleanly represented, and animations are kept simple but charming.
Core gameplay loop is pretty addictive.
One More Island is a cheerful, colony-building simulation that starts with a promising blend of exploration, production management, and light narrative humor before gradually revealing both its strengths and its structural constraints.
The pixel-art world is bright, the interface is clean, and the early progression feels intuitive as you establish a dock, harvest the first resources, and watch your settlement take shape.
The same can be said for the sound design: it is unobtrusive, calm, and keeps the experience grounded in a comfortable rhythm.
Theme by theme
Every theme is scored by what reviewers actually said about it, not just whether they recommended the game.
Ranked by how many sampled reviews mention each topic. A topic sits in a column by what reviewers said about that topic; the percentage beside it is how many of them recommended the game anyway.
Should you buy it now?
Crit’s read on the price, from Steam price history.
Currently $19.99. The lowest we've tracked is $1.99.
The data behind the verdict
For the players who want the receipts.
We’ll surface hours-played once playtime ingestion ships.
If you liked this one
Reviewed games that overlap most with this one.
